It’s time for a hard reset. Let’s put the person in charge of making the hiring decision in charge of the entire process!

Hiring managers need to step up and measure their success by the quality of the people they’ve hired. But the metric of success is not measured on Day 1. It’s measured throughout the year.

Below is the why and the how. And here’s the legal validation to prevent the excuses.

In this approach we need to add these two new metrics of hiring success:

New Employee Experience (NEX): A measure of a new hire’s satisfaction, engagement and performance based on their Q4 scores (the most important Gallup Q12 scores) throughout the first year.

Hiring Manager Leadership Score (MLS): The running average of their NEX scores throughout their first year. With AI we can now measure this in real time. This helps identify problems as they’re occurring.

And we’ll use a new approach for training them by immersing them in the process while they’re actually filling jobs and interviewing candidates. In this Performance-based Hiring model we’ve embedded post-hire success into the pre-hire process. Tracking the NEX and MLS metrics acts ensures the process is working.


This report card is based on 20 years of hiring results. This is failing grade! It’s worse when you consider that companies spend over $100 billion annually trying to fix the problem and the havn’t. That’s why major disruption is needed.

Report Card on HR’s Ability to Drive Workforce Engagement

Engagement is now at a 10 year low! First-year turnover remains high. And far too many new hires regret their decision within months.

AI may soon automate much of the hiring process, but it won’t solve the real problem. Because the problem isn’t with tools, it’s with ownership.

For too long, hiring has been treated as an HR process. And by most business standards, HR has failed to flip the switch. We’ve optimized for efficiency and compliance, not performance and retention. Even with better branding, faster workflows, and smarter screening tools, we’re still losing too many good people too soon.


Hiring Is a Business Decision – Not an HR Transaction

In any high-performing organization, the person accountable for outcomes should also be accountable for the people driving those outcomes. That’s not HR. That’s the hiring manager.

And yet in most companies today, hiring managers are detached from the front end of the process. They’re not even trained to hire or to recruit or to coach or to manage. Instead, HR defines the job based on compliance not on reality and then filters the candidates based on this criteria – while the manager waits to say yes or no. This disconnect leads to superficial evaluations, misaligned expectations, and ultimately, new hires who were recruited into the wrong version of the job.

The solution is simple but non-negotiable: hiring must be led by the hiring manager. HR remains a critical partner – but not the owner. AI will streamline the process. HR will coach and support. But the manager must lead.


AI Enables a Shift in Focus – from Process to People

AI’s growing role in hiring changes the tactical landscape. It can source talent, match resumes, predict fit, and even automate scheduling. But what AI can’t do is evaluate how well someone fits into a team’s culture, how a candidate will respond to a specific manager’s style, or how clearly the role has been defined for success.

In this way, AI removes the noise – and raises the stakes for the human decision-makers. They will be expected to step up, take ownership, and focus on the part of hiring that matters most: selecting, onboarding, and developing high-potential people who drive the business forward.

Hiring must become a core leadership responsibility, not an HR-administered task. HR should remain a strategic enabler by providing tools, structure, and advisory support, but the hiring manager must own the outcome. That means being held accountable not just for making a hire, but for launching a successful new team member and proactively ensuring they succeed. Their failure or success then becomes the hiring manager’s responsibility.

HR has had their chance. They’ve spent billions year after year and failed. Let’s put the responsibility on those who really make the hiring decision – the hiring manager.


How to Convert Hiring Managers Into Super Coaches and Leaders

Gift them the hiring manager handbook of success.

Put them through hands-on hiring and recruiting training as part of filling their next open requisition.

Have them learn the rules of the game by playing “Moneyball for HR!”This is how they’ll find some hidden gems sadly overlooked by today’s modern HR tech stack.

Reach out for an instant demofor any critical assignment you’re trying to fill.